
What Actually Makes Therapy Work? Our Team’s Answer Might Surprise You.
Welcome back to our Pondworks Clinical Inquiry Series. In a mental health landscape increasingly dominated by transactional, 15-minute med checks and absentee physician supervision, we believe our patients deserve better. That is why our team invests over 500 hours a year in dedicated clinical supervision and education. We are pulling back the curtain on our bi-weekly Clinical Inquiry meetings to show you exactly how we “walk the walk.” This series is your inside look at how we ensure our practice is driven by deep, relationally focused discussion, rather than just writing a quick prescription.
How Our January Clinical Inquiry Started
Our Clinical Inquiry at Pondworks started with: coffee, a question, and an open invitation for the team to push back. Our January session opened with Dr. Kim posing something deceptively simple to our assembled team: “Can we create a cohesive approach to delivering biopsychosocial care? And can we start simply — then enjoy a movement toward developing sophistication?”
The word “enjoy” was deliberate. Dr. Kim underlined it. The goal was not just clinical rigor for its own sake, but building something that would energize providers, give them better tools for difficult cases, and create the kind of in-house communication that makes a practice actually feel like a team rather than a collection of individual providers.
So What Is a ‘Common Factor,’ Exactly?
The discussion opened with a question to the room: can anyone define common factors? One provider immediately went to application — asking whether we were talking about specific diagnostic categories, personality disorders. It was a reasonable instinct, and Dr. Kim used it to draw the first important distinction.
Common factors are not diagnosis-specific. They are not a protocol you pull out for borderline patients or a technique reserved for trauma cases. They are the ingredients present in every effective therapeutic encounter — across CBT, DBT, psychodynamic work, medication management, all of it. The example that landed: trust. Would everyone in the room raise their hand to say trust is a factor in every therapy? Every hand went up. That, Dr. Kim explained, is a common factor.
“Common factors should be something that’s utilized across diagnostic categories and is in every individually specific therapy. Trust transcends all boundaries. That kind of gives you an idea of what we mean.” — Dr. Kim, Clinical Inquiry, January 2025
Trust, he added, speaks to the biggest umbrella concept of the series: therapeutic alliance.
The Research Is Messier Than Most Clinicians Admit To
Before diving into alliance, Dr. Kim did something that distinguishes Pondworks’ approach from the confident over-simplifications relayed in high-volume psychiatric care.
We know therapy has at least a moderate effect. That part is settled. What is not settled is which specific technique — the CBT protocol, the behavioral activation homework — is doing the heavy lifting, or whether the common, relational factors underneath it are. A landmark review by Cuijpers and colleagues in 2019 explicitly concluded that substantial differences between common and specific factors are difficult to define.
Dr. Kim’s own view: the distinction matters, but our measurement tools are not yet good enough to capture it cleanly. Most psychotherapy research is built on CBT studies with broad, symptom-based outcome metrics. Those metrics miss a lot. The research is not wrong — the lens is just narrow. And that narrowness, he argued, is exactly why a practice that goes beyond symptom checklists is treating something the data cannot fully see. It is why simple, common factors based therapies tend to perform as well as branded therapies.
The Y Model: Starting Simply, Moving Toward Sophistication
To give the team a visual frame, Dr. Kim returned to a model used in residency training across multiple Pondworks sessions: the Y model of psychotherapy competencies. The stem of the Y represents the common factors — therapeutic alliance, collaboration, basic listening and reflection skills, the relational foundation every provider starts with regardless of experience level. The branches represent specific modalities: psychodynamic therapy on one side, CBT on the other, with room for additional branches (DBT, MBT, and others) as providers develop.
The framing matters because it addresses something real about the Pondworks team: everyone comes in with different training backgrounds and different levels of clinical experience. Most providers entered from pathways where the ‘bio’ was their job and the ‘psychosocial’ was explicitly someone else’s. One provider put it plainly in the discussion: “Biopsychosocial was kind of segmented. Your bio and their psychosocial, instead of it being the same person doing it.”
The Y model is an answer to that artificial segmentation. You start in the stem — the common factors every provider can build from day one. You grow into the branches over time, through individual supervision, Clinical Inquiries, and ongoing education. You also become a much better provider of split care for appropriate situations. The sophistication is the journey. The common factors are what let you begin.
The goal is not to force everyone into the same technique. It is to make sure everyone starts from the same foundation: a genuine attempt to understand the patient as a full human being, not just a diagnostic category with a medication list.
What the Common Factor List Actually Looks Like
Dr. Kim walked the team through the commonly cited list, noting that different authors give different versions but the Venn diagram of agreement is substantial:
- Therapist empathy — warmth, respect, genuine human support
- Patient’s expectation of outcome — how hopeful and ready for change the patient arrives, and what they believe can actually shift
- Cultural adaptation — fitting evidence-based care to the patient’s own beliefs about what their problem is and what effective help looks like
- Therapist effects — the individual qualities of the provider that research shows independently influence outcomes
- Therapeutic alliance — the broad umbrella that arguably contains most of the above
On patient expectation, a provider asked the question directly: is that just how hopeful they are? His answer was that it is that, but also something more — it is yoked to what the patient believes change looks like, and what they hope treatment can do. Sussing that out early, he argued, is some of the most important work in an initial evaluation.
Another provider brought up a pattern that will be familiar to anyone doing psychiatric evaluations: a patient comes in wanting medication, but what you observe suggests the real work is relational or interpersonal. Do you give them the medication anyway? Dr. Kim’s answer was practical: “That’s kind of like judo — rolling with where they are, if you can. Oftentimes what they bring in is not incorrect. It’s just one leg of the stool.”
In Part 2, the Clinical Inquiry turns to what happened when the team went deep on the single most researched common factor of all — and what the data actually shows about why the relationship between patient and provider may be the treatment itself.
We hope this look inside our Clinical Inquiry process demonstrates the Pondworks difference. When we say we reject the ‘15-minute med check’ model, this rigorous, behind-the-scenes work is exactly how we back it up. Bringing our Clinical Inquiry from the meeting room directly into your sessions is how our entire team — from Dr. Kim to our highly trained Advanced Practice Providers — ensures you receive care that goes beyond a quick prescription. If you are looking for a practice that invests in depth and relationship, we invite you to explore our About Us Page or reach out to our Austin clinic when you are ready.